Tuesday, 26 February 2008

Media coverage of Eduardo's horrific injury


One of this week's major sport stories was the injury to Arsenal's Eduardo.

Birmingham City’s fantastic 10 man performance was overshadowed in the press by the horrific injury to Arsenal’s Eduardo. Eduardo dislocated his ankle and broke his leg due to a challenge from Birmingham’s Martin Taylor (which warranted a red card).

It was one of the worst leg breaks ever to be seen in football. This raises the issue that should the injury have been shown on television and should the papers have shocking photos of the incident?

Above: Eduardo
(Image from Elsie Emms -Flickr)
During the game, ‘Sky Sports’ did a fantastic job of reporting the injury. Commentators told the viewers that they could not show the incident in a replay as it was “too shocking.”

‘Sky’ reported that the medical staff were in shock, it was then clear that this was no normal injury. Although Sky’s website did show a photo of Eduardo lying down in pain, it was not as distasteful as other sites.

It was interesting discovering how the tabloid and broadsheet newspaper websites reported the issue. It was surprising that ‘The Times’ article also showed one of the images. It may have been expected that ‘The Times’ would have been perhaps, more respectful and possibly not produced the shocking images.

The BBC website did hold back when reporting the issue, the website does not show images of the actual leg break.

Perhaps the most distasteful article was found on the ‘The Daily Mail’ website. The website produces an article with two shocking images of the tackle. With no warning the photos just come up as you click on the article. The same page even has a link to a photo gallery of ‘football’s worst injuries.’ Out of all the media coverage of the incident, ‘The Daily Mail’ did not seem to hold back and was certainly the most shocking.

It is in no doubt that these injuries have to be reported and the readers and viewers want to see images of the tackle. However, some may suggest that ‘The Daily Mail’ went too far with their article on the injury and also other related articles.
What do you think of The Daily Mail's coverage of the Eduardo incident? Take the poll on the blog to have your say.

Tuesday, 19 February 2008

Negative press surrounds Murray after Open win

On the February 17, Andy Murray cruised to victory over Mario Ancic to win the open 13 final in Marseille. This was Murray's fifth ATP title in his career and his second this year. Despite this impressive form, controversy and negative press still surrounds the young Scot.

There are five articles featuring Murray on the tennis section of ‘The Sun’ website. The majority of these are negative. These articles feature the apparent fall out between Murray and his Brother and David Nalbandian criticising Murray for dropping out of the Davis Cup.

Yes, it is true that Murray did drop out of the Davis Cup due to an apparent injury. This was criticised by many as Murray played in the open 13 almost a week later, this questioned the injury. Although it is a controversial issue, Murray’s decision may have been proven to be correct as after all he did go on to win the open.

Murray’s decision is similar to that of David Bentley before the Under 21 European Championships. Bentley opted to withdraw from the squad due to tiredness over the course of the previous season. This decision was heavily criticised by the press, the football fans and Bentley’s manager David Bentley.

However, although Bentley has been in impressive form this season, his decision has not and never will be proven to be a correct one. This is where Murray perhaps is given a bit of breathing space from fans and the press, after all he did go on to win a trophy a week later.

The tennis section on ‘The Telegraph’ website shed a more positive light on the issue. There were two articles featuring Murray. One headlined “Brotherly love an inspiration for Murray.” This article discussed how there was no fall out between the brothers by saying:

"Anybody hoping the Murray brothers might have a major falling out over Andy's decision to miss the Davis Cup tie in Argentina are likely to be sorely disappointed."
The differences between the two websites were noticeable. ‘The Sun’ did report the victory in a positive way but then surrounded and possibly over-shadowed this by reporting apparent fall-outs and blasts at Murray. ‘The Telegraph’ reported the facts well and insisted there were no fall-outs between the Murray brothers.

Although the controversy surrounding Murray should be reported, there should be more praise on Murray for not only doing Britain proud but he is setting an example to young Tennis players.

This was surprising coming from a British press who demand top class sport from the nation, who are always quick to criticise bad performances.

Tuesday, 12 February 2008

Munich tribute - Newspaper coverage

There were a lot of interesting points to note in Monday's (10th February 2008) newspaper coverage of the Manchester derby. Not only was there the match to report from but also the Munich tribute.

The Sun's back page was devoted to the tribute, the headline read: " Manchester is United 50 years on." The photograph fitted the headline well as it showed City and United fans paying tributes by holding up their scarves during the silence.

'The Sun' concentrated on the tribute with brief mentions of the actual game. This was surprising considering the inspiring City performance, however there was a double page article inside on the game itself.

'The Times' had a great article on the derby game but I found it disappointing when it mentioned on the back page that fireworks had gone off outside the stadium during the silence. Although it should be mentioned, it could have possibly been avoided on the back page, therefore not attracting attention to these individuals who were accused of setting the fireworks off.

Martin Samuel, Chief Football Correspondent at Old Trafford produced a great article (can be accessed in the links section of blog) summing up the event and the game itself. Overall the newspaper coverage of the event was impressive and I was pleasantly surprised by 'The Sun’, which featured a fantastic back page.

What has surprised me about the internet coverage of the whole event was the praise heaped on Manchester City fans for staying silent during the minute. There is no doubt that City fans behaved immaculately but surely staying quiet is a minimum requirement at moments like these.

The whole event was a day to remember and the newspaper articles can definitely play a major part in the football fan’s scrap book.

Tuesday, 5 February 2008

Introduction

My name is Craig Coulthard and I am a student at the University of Central Lancashire. For this module I will be commenting on not only what is being reported in sports news but also how it is reported. Feel free to comment on any blogs I post.

Thanks,
Craig.

CCoulthard@uclan.ac.uk