Tuesday, 19 February 2008

Negative press surrounds Murray after Open win

On the February 17, Andy Murray cruised to victory over Mario Ancic to win the open 13 final in Marseille. This was Murray's fifth ATP title in his career and his second this year. Despite this impressive form, controversy and negative press still surrounds the young Scot.

There are five articles featuring Murray on the tennis section of ‘The Sun’ website. The majority of these are negative. These articles feature the apparent fall out between Murray and his Brother and David Nalbandian criticising Murray for dropping out of the Davis Cup.

Yes, it is true that Murray did drop out of the Davis Cup due to an apparent injury. This was criticised by many as Murray played in the open 13 almost a week later, this questioned the injury. Although it is a controversial issue, Murray’s decision may have been proven to be correct as after all he did go on to win the open.

Murray’s decision is similar to that of David Bentley before the Under 21 European Championships. Bentley opted to withdraw from the squad due to tiredness over the course of the previous season. This decision was heavily criticised by the press, the football fans and Bentley’s manager David Bentley.

However, although Bentley has been in impressive form this season, his decision has not and never will be proven to be a correct one. This is where Murray perhaps is given a bit of breathing space from fans and the press, after all he did go on to win a trophy a week later.

The tennis section on ‘The Telegraph’ website shed a more positive light on the issue. There were two articles featuring Murray. One headlined “Brotherly love an inspiration for Murray.” This article discussed how there was no fall out between the brothers by saying:

"Anybody hoping the Murray brothers might have a major falling out over Andy's decision to miss the Davis Cup tie in Argentina are likely to be sorely disappointed."
The differences between the two websites were noticeable. ‘The Sun’ did report the victory in a positive way but then surrounded and possibly over-shadowed this by reporting apparent fall-outs and blasts at Murray. ‘The Telegraph’ reported the facts well and insisted there were no fall-outs between the Murray brothers.

Although the controversy surrounding Murray should be reported, there should be more praise on Murray for not only doing Britain proud but he is setting an example to young Tennis players.

This was surprising coming from a British press who demand top class sport from the nation, who are always quick to criticise bad performances.

No comments: